Comments Subscribe to Personal Liberty Digest™ News Feed Subscribe to Personal Liberty Digest™ 

FAIR Report Cautions Against Democrats' Amnesty Plans

April 8, 2010 by  

FAIR report cautions against Democrats' amnesty plans As the Democrats are turning their sights towards immigration reform, a prominent advocacy organization has warned that an amnesty for illegal immigrants would be detrimental to American workers’ prospects.

According to the report from the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) entitled Amnesty and the American Worker, record levels of immigration during the 2000s have added new workers to the labor force faster than the economy has been able to create new jobs.

That is why the organization has criticized the amnesty idea supported by many Democrats, saying that at a time when some 25 million Americans are either unemployed or involuntarily working part-time, amnesty would entitle the estimated 7.5 million illegal aliens to keep their current jobs, and compete with American workers for any new jobs.

"It is unconscionable that at a time of devastatingly high unemployment, our nation’s leaders seem determined to forge ahead with legislation without even considering the harm it might cause," said Dan Stein, president of FAIR.

He also disputed assertions that the move would boost the U.S. economy, saying the benefits would accrue almost entirely to the amnestied aliens and their direct employers.

The latest figures from the Bureau of Labor Statistics suggest the unemployment rate in March remained unchanged at 9.7 percent. ADNFCR-1961-ID-19706445-ADNFCR

Personal Liberty News Desk

Facebook Conversations

Join the Discussion:
View Comments to “FAIR Report Cautions Against Democrats' Amnesty Plans”

Comment Policy: We encourage an open discussion with a wide range of viewpoints, even extreme ones, but we will not tolerate racism, profanity or slanderous comments toward the author(s) or comment participants. Make your case passionately, but civilly. Please don't stoop to name calling. We use filters for spam protection. If your comment does not appear, it is likely because it violates the above policy or contains links or language typical of spam. We reserve the right to remove comments at our discretion.

Is there news related to personal liberty happening in your area? Contact us at newstips@personalliberty.com

  • American liberal

    Bottom line… If you don’t like our president.. Then get off your Butts and work… Because I don’t care what you think… You had your chance and screwed the country bigtime.. If we lose , then I keep working..

    • zack

      American liberal no sense in putting on your working boots now, because the idiots “as you call Bush” like yourself that do not have sense enough to see the writing on the wall that obama the Muslim, and Communist is taking this country to hell, and won’t even salute the American flag, then you need to wake up, because you are a damn MORON if you believe he,”obama” is for America. You can take obama and his Chicago Mafia,and go straight to HELL.

    • http://?? Joe H.

      am lib,
      you obviously DO care what we think or you wouldn’t be here!!! PLEASE CARE A LOT LESS!!!!

  • American liberal

    If you didn’t think Bushs presidency fascist , and if you didn’t think he trampled allover the constitution, if you didn’t think he ruined this countrys economy and shoved his agenda down are throats then your an idiot… Bushs administration was a mirrored copy of Hitlers Nazis and some of you have the Gall to claim President Obamas taking your freedom?.. By the way.. What freedom has he taken?.. Because we already have states with this samekind of healthcare and like I said you can keep your own insurance if you like … That’s not socialism.. Did any of you think the Patriot act gave the goverment to much power? I did, and still do…. When Bush went around the FISA courts to illegally wiretap… Was that tyranny?… The courts have ruled aginst Bush… And president Obama said he’ll use the Fisa courts for wiretapping and get a warrent.. The proper way…were Bushs secret prisons tyranny?…

  • chuck b

    reagan may have made a mistake in granting amnesty to the illegals and the amnesty bill bush was trying to get through was a mistake. the people rose up and stopped it. what is the reason for granting these illegals amnesty? we have laws against what they have done and now we are supposed to turn our heads and say ok everything is forgiven? i don’t think so, they walked into this country now they can walk back or swim i don’t care. most of the people coming in to the u.s. without proper clearance have no allegiance to the u.s. and want to live their culture here and at the same time live on the dole of the taxpayers. send them back. and like i said some of you liberals can go too! lol

    • eyeswideopen

      chuck, the corporations who want cheap labor are the reasons that there is no enforcement of our laws. Gee, who could that be?? It is the same corporations who we subsidze with our tax dollars. Don’t forget it is socialism for the corporations and free market for the middle class. If it wasn’t why do you think that the enforcement has lasped producing our current situation? Let me see, Reagan granted 3.2 million amnesty in 86.Next President a Republican, Bush,– no action, Clinton, dem with repub controlled congress,– no action, Bush repub with repub controlled congress–no action. It appears that the repub mantra of no regulations, no rules, no government interference in the market place or our lives has produced this large quanity of illegal immigrants. So who do you think was against enforcing our laws? Yep, the party in power didn’t want to lose that cheap labor pool of immigrants. Blame yourselves you had the chance and did nothing.

  • American liberal

    I didn’t like my tax dollars going to fund Bushs Iraqi adventure and I didn’t like Bush borrowing trillions from China, I didn’t like Bush and the republicans running our economy into an economic ditch… So I wentout and worked for the democrats and then for president Obamas campaign and we won… We the people voted in President Obama…. I didn’t pout or threaten anyone.. I worked .. And I’m still working for our president… So Chuckie… All I can tell you is to be a big boy and get out and work .. Stop crying and whining line some spoiled child that didn’t get his way…. We won… You lost… Do you understand how a democracy works?.. Let me tell you, because it appears you don’t understand…. The guys who win ( us) get to push our agenda.. You got your war aginst Iraq, you got your tax cuts for the rich… And now we’ve given those without healthcare access to healthcare… And if you still don’t get it……. Tough…

    • tedcrawford

      If, as you state, you didn’t like bush funding wars, borrowing money from china, and running our economy into the ground, HOW in this, or any other, world can you support an administration that is doing exactlly that, only on steroids??? Now that, my friends, is progressive “logic”, and I rest my case! Remember November!!!

      • TIME

        Hi Ted,
        No Nano Witt – failed in logic so he really can’t quite grasp the idea of logic.
        Its like tossing snow balls at Pluto, it looks good on paper but the application fails every time.

      • eyeswideopen

        tedcrawford, so you logic is that if we do it, it is ok, and we have the option of doing the same thing again in the future, BUT if the opposing party does the same thing we did, then it is WRONG!!! Dude that is some kind of logic, you must have gone to a private college, as they don’t teach that type of illogical reasoning in those liberal colleges.

  • American liberal

    Chuckie… Was Ronald Reagan a liberal when he granted amnasty when he was president?… Or why didn’t Bush do something about illegal immigration.. Because if he had we wouldn’t be having this conversation about immigrants would we…. You’re gonna have to have your tantrum for the next 3 years until the Presidents either voted out or he wins the election…and until you can think of a real candidate your just gonna have to pout…

  • chuck b

    then, if thats the case, the barry bill was a copy of romneys ? and romneys bill is a failure, the dem libs knew this and still crammed this monstrocity down our throats. thats real logic. don’t you think they could be a little more original than that. face it the health care bill is a flat out failure and the people who wrote it are worse. yes i do watch and listen to fox news and i’ll bet you listen to abc and the other un=american media. you talk about uneducated, most thinking people have turned off the left wing media. you should listen to fox and catch up with the truth.

  • American liberal

    Theirs also nothing in the healthcare bill that hasn’t already been done By conservatives..in fact a large part of the bill was taken from Mitt Romneys bill… Richard Nixon also tried to do the very samething while he was president….so when you hear these rightys talking about socialism in this bill you know it’s an uneducated Fox news watcher…

  • chuck b

    you must be delusional if you think this is not going to effect the quality of the care you might be seeking. do you think for one minute this bill is going to reduce your medical costs? it may if you are on welfare, but, you didn’t have cost anyway. this bill is going to raise your tax and lessen the care you may need. your insurance premiums are going to go up on private ins. and the waiting time will be excessive.
    this bill was intended to embrace the illegals. a payback for the latino vote. we did not need this kind of reform, barry needed the tax.
    if you and your liberal friends like the public option so much, then move to canada, a lot of the canadians would like to trade places. then they wouldn’t have to travel to the u.s. for care they couldn’t get at home. of course, you liberals will be willing to pay more for the illegals to get first class care at other peoples expense, not yours. the democrats are on their way out and some of the rino repubs, so enjoy your socialist dream while you can. jose and family will thank you.

    • American liberal

      Chuck… Correct.. My taxes won’t go up.. Neither will yours , unless you’re making 250,000 $ or more…. And Chuck… Have you been living under a rock?.. The bill passed so I don’t need to go to Canada.. And I’m already insured by Cigna.. And guess what?.. I can keep my own insurance… Chuck you don’t understand that your already paying for those that don’t have insurance… That’s right, when those that didn’t have insurance got sick they went to the emergency room to be treated.. Do you understand that the cost of those emergency rooms visits were already passed on to you ?..And Chuck.. I think it would be a better idea if you left America.. I like my President, I like the healthcare bill , I like our goverment and I like our country… Your the one that hates the goverment, hates our country, hates our president and hates America… Chuck, your kind of an oddball… You Tea baggers are only about 20 % of this country .. And of those 20% only half of them are really hardcore nutcases.. The other 10% are just uneducated malcontents… You couldn’t even tell me who’s leading your party..can you?.. So far I’ve just seen nutcases like Sarah ” Hollywood ” Palin and Michelle Bachman… And you know niether one of them has the IQ of used gum… You’re just an angry little boy that’s had to much sugar..

      • TIME

        Nano Witt,
        You don’t work so your tax’s will never go up, now will they? Come on be honest.

      • http://?? Joe H.

        EO, hwat do you think is going to happen to those that went to the ER once in a very great while when care is free for them??? those visits and Dr. visits are only going to increase!!!

  • American liberal

    The healthcare bill isn’t socialism… You have the choice of keeping the healthcare you have now if you want… You people don’t understand what socialism is… All this bill does is give people access to medical care and coverage if they need it….. You don’t understand that your already paying for people who don’t have insurance …. That’s why your healthcare bills are so high… They should go down on a few years…. Who do you think pays for the uninsured when they go to the emergancy room for treatment?.. You pay.. It’s passed on to you right now.. I don’t know why you don’t understand this… With the healthcare bill they can now see a doctor instead of the very expensive emergency room…. It will be clear soon.. And as more people see the advantage it will become popular… If not then the president will be a 1 term president , you rightys will be happy and the republicans can finish destroying the country..

    • http://?? Joe H.

      amlib,
      Get laid off and go on the government plan and see if you can go back to your plan after you get called back!!!! You will find out that once on the Gov plan you can never go back!!!!

  • chuck b

    unlightened one

    the so called 77% when polled had no idea what was in this bill. only the welfare cases would accept the single payer option. you claim this is not socialism? the republicans were right in not voting for this garbage bill and hopefully it will be un-funded if the republicans get a majority this fall. death panels? what do you call it when people can determine what kind of care you should be entitled to beyond what your doctor may request? (death panel). your polling expectations are wrong it is your wishful thinking. this is the democratic waterloo or should i say progressives. the democratic party is of a socialist nature it goes along with their weak mentality

  • Enlightened one

    I also wouldn’t get to giddy about Obamas low numbers right now….Ronald Reagans were similar at this point……. Also, the low democrats polls don’t mean the countrys ready to embrace republicans, they’re polls are pretty poor also… A lot can happen in the next 6 months and I’d still bet president Obama will beat anyone I see from the right in 2012… But like I said.. Anythings possible.. We all know how fickle this countrys voters can be..

    • TIME

      EO,
      By 2012, BarryO will be “100% exposed” thus he will be leaving the white house, post haste. No matter what the polls say the Mass of American people will VOTE him out of office with ease.

      The numbers are growing daily of those disenfranchised with BarryO’s rhetoric.

      • http://?? Joe H.

        Time,
        EO is overlooking one glaring fact!! Obummer is no Reagan!!!! Not even close! Obummer couldn’t light Reagans cigarrette!!!!

    • eyeswideopen

      Eo, all it will take is for the conservatives/repubs to fight Obama on this Nuke treaty and they will known as the party who wants to destroy the earth. Their Hero Ronald Reagan tried to get Nukes banned, as did Bush Sr.but they won’t acknowledge that, they will push forward and prevent the world from downsizing the arsenal held by those we deem to be our foes. Such logic will prevail and when the nukes fall into the hands of terrorists, we have no one to blame but the conservatives/repubs.

      • zack

        eyes uuhh wrong again.The signing of the nuke treaty just lifted Palin ahead of obama and the republicans over the democrats by a some what large margin. Palin made obama look like a whipped mule when the news anchor asked obama what he thought of Palin’s statement. Uh Uh I I Uh Oh Uh I well I want comment right now. Sound like he had a mouth full of $h!T.

  • Enlightened one

    Time… If you go back and look at the polls on healthcare just before The president took office and after the election you’ll see that more than 70 and as much as 77 % favored the reform… It’s because the single payer option wasn’t included that the poll numbers are now so low.. And the fact that The President allowed the republicans to drag it on and on… I believe when eople really findout what’s in the bill and it’s exposed that it’s not socialism or their are no death panels and the rest of the nonsense the rightwing says the bill contains… The polls will pick back up

    • tedcrawford

      The Republicans didn’t stop anything! obama and the democrats had over 9 months with a super majority and couldn’t pass anything! Only a blind person or a left-wing zealot, could fail to realize just how bad this bill must really be!

    • TIME

      EO,
      Political rhetoric during an election, as well such polls taken at that time are not worth the space they take up.
      Once people see how transparent the person who is pushing something truly is – then all the prior polls value’s are gone.

      As I noted after the vote; 70% Plus were against it, that number will only grow, why – the bag of tricks has just been somewhat exposed now and people are not happy with what was in that bag of tricks at all. No its not that they did not think it went far enough that group is so small that its a single diget in value, as in all of 1.52% of the gross number of voters.

      The Republicans did nothing, nor could they have done anything to stop the noted bill, if you have nealry two votes to every one, the smaller vote count has no effect, thus the Republicans had no effect.
      So please stop with the worthless rhetoric that twitts like Katie Q quacks out as fact, its of no value to anyone who has a brain single cell still working.

      Thus your claim about the said Republicans holding back anything – is nul and void.
      It was in fact the Democrats themselfs that held back this plan, and why many Democrats failed to vote for the said bill.

      Those that played games with it like the congress person from MI will pay for his acts by loosing his seat in congress, as well will nearly all who voted for this costly bill.
      Many have already walked away knowing full well they crooked themselfs right out of a job.

      As well until this bills “laws suits” have been settled its not going anywhere.

      Thus as that goes more states will join in with the outstanding law suit over time. As a matter of fact I fell strongly that by December 2010 there will be 30 states if not more that will have joined in this said law suit.

      And by next year thats January 2011 there will be 25% more on top of that number, plus the case will not even get to court perhaps even until 2012 on the early side, and by the time it dose, the State count in the noted Law Suit may be 45 if not all.

      But thanks for your thoughts – saddly they are not accurate.

  • http://verizon kbab777

    Round up all the liberals, doe that include you too chuck?

    • http://verizon kbab777

      Correction,Does that include you chuck b?

      • chuck b

        kbab777

        all the liberals with some republicans such as lindsay graham and mitch mcconnel and other wimpy rino’s. its time to clean the country up. and i’ll stay here, thanks.

      • Claire

        chuck b — And I agree with you on this. Round up all of them and throw them out.

  • chuck b

    a better idea, round up all the liberals and ship them to mexico. that will solve 90% of our problems. we might throw in a few republicans too.

    • angel-wanna-be

      LOOK CHUCK b, We accept & know why a Liberals post on Conservative forums. For the most part it’s just to say stupid sh*t, rustle up the sheep and then report to your liberal news media, that the Conservatives are Fringe lunatics. People would probably be willing to believe some of your rhetoric, but the problem is, the Liberals are the ones in power._The Soros backed Bush bashing is no longer working, so you might as well take your dollies and go home!

      • chuck b

        angel-wanna-be

        your barking up the wrong tree or smoking dummy dust. first off, i’m not a liberal. are you sure you understand what my last post is saying?

      • http://?? Joe H.

        angel,
        Chuck b is one of us!!!

    • http://verizon kbab777

      Actually you are right chuck b.

    • tedcrawford

      If you make that progressives I’m with you 110%

  • Airangel

    Lets let all foreigners run our country…this just in…ABC banning the wearing of anything AMERICAN!!! Who owns them? Serious…is America being sold-out from under us?

    Even Barbara Walters said that this was going to hurt ABC badly. As you know, she works for ABC.

    This should make your blood boil…it DOES mine!

    “ABC NEWS BANS FLAG LAPEL PINS!

    YESTERDAY THE BRASS AT ABC NEWS ISSUED ORDERS FORBIDDING REPORTERS TO WEAR LAPEL PIN AMERICAN FLAGS OR OTHER PATRIOTIC INSIGNIA. THEIR REASONING WAS THAT ABC SHOULD REMAIN NEUTRAL ABOUT ‘CAUSES’.

    SINCE WHEN IS SUPPORT FOR PREVENTING DEATH AND DESTRUCTION SOME SORT OF A ‘CAUSE’? SINCE WHEN IS PATRIOTISM TO BE DISCOURAGED?

    I URGE YOU TO BOYCOTT ABC AND ITS SPONSORS AND AFFILIATES. WE ARE SLOWLY LOSING EVERYTHING OUR COUNTRY STANDS FOR AND EVERYTHING OUR MEN AND WOMEN FOUGHT AND DIED TO PRESERVE! PLEASE FORWARD THIS TO AS MANY AS YOU CAN.

    THIS HAS BEEN VERIFIED THROUGH:

    http://www.snopes.com/rumors/noflags.asp

    THIS ONE NEEDS TO BE CIRCULATED…QUICKLY! BOYCOTT ABC!

    • angel-wanna-be

      Give me a frickin’ break!___I’m gonna do what neighbors of our did and they are DEMOCRATS!___They posted a sign on their property,4 MONTHS AGO…. it states__”STOP AMERICAN SOCIALISM NOW!”

    • Claire

      Airangel—-Is this true? Did they really ban the wearing of flag lapel pins?

    • tedcrawford

      The company I worked for during the 9/11 crisis made the same statement about flags on our hard-hats. The next day almost every man had a flag on their hat! The company backed down!

      • Claire

        Well, come Monday I will be sure to wear my flag pin. I’ll be willing to bet they won’t say one word to me!

      • cr747

        Claire,,
        On the tail section of my planes I have this Hugh UNITED STATES AMERICAN FLAG that the president won’t even look at when landed..I know it chars his but when he has to walk by them,,and see those big Flags!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

      • Claire

        cr747– Good for you! If I had a plane I would do the same. I have always had a flag on my van. Not real big, but it is noticeable.

  • kate8

    Illegal immigration is just another aspect of the plan to destroy America. It demoralizes citizens, creates more crime and chaos, and wastes more taxpayer money.

    The truth is, the NAU is alive and well. I think they put a new name on it. We no longer have borders. They just haven’t officially told us yet.

    This administration has demonstrated loud and clear that it will not be hindered by the will of the people. We have been removed from the
    debate, as we have become a “nuisance” (according to BO himself).

    • angel-wanna-be

      kATE8, “ABSO-FREAKIN-LUTELY!!!”

      • Claire

        Sorry, girls–none of the administratations have done a dang thing about the illegals. Sure some were granted amnesty and then the administrations dropped the ball. They are ALL guilty of doing nothing. Regarding this issue, the Repubs didn’t do a thing-same as the Liberals. They have refused to deal with it. If any blame is to be placed, then all of them are to blame.

      • Claire

        Good grief. “administrations”

      • eyeswideopen

        Finally, the voice of reason and fairness. Hands clapping.

      • http://?? Joe H.

        and empty head echoing!!!

      • zack

        hands a clapping, feet in the air dancing, and blowing gas. lmao lol WWWHHHOOOOOOO

    • tedcrawford

      Kate: Lets hope we can REALLY be a nuisance in November!!!

  • eddie47d

    We’ve had this problem for over a century and still squabbling. Every so many years we have a shortage of workers and businesses ask the government to allow more help to come in.These businesses hire immigrants by the hundreds and thousands during these periods. When the economy gets bad we scream deportation and treat these workers like they are less than human. Why should they constantly be required to live a nomadic life. Their living conditions aren’t going to improve if we keep treating them like garbage in and garbage out. We should always keep the border closed if that’s the will of the American people. If our American companies need workers like they have in the past then America will not be productive and that will be our loss. If we choose to allow immigrants in this country to do our work them treat them with respect and give them some stability.

    • http://?? Joe H.

      eddie47d-cup,
      There was a meat packing plant in Georgia raided a couple of years ago and a goodly number of illegals busted and deported. these workers were making an average of 12.00 an hour. Now remember if you can, that average means some were making more. within one week, all the jobs had been filled by U.S. citizens!!! That belies your “fact” that there are “shortages” of American workers!!!! I know of quite a few people that would be glad to work for that wage when compaired to the dollar store wage they are making to get by!!!

    • DamnYankee

      Stability? Where is the stability for our Veterans or the elderly? Many of our veterans are living in the streets; many elderly are eating dogfood, or choosing between paying for needed drugs or losing their homes. Where are their STABILITY?

      • http://?? Joe H.

        Yankee,
        Once you get another 30 million on medicare it’s only gonna get worse!!!

  • Dale

    A country that doesn’t control its borders . . . eventually ceases to be a country. Its not just mexicans that are coming accross the southern border, undesirables from all over the world are walking into the US and taking advantage of leftist states who just can’t give them enough. It’s time to round up the illegals and send them home.
    Watched the Bamster answer a question at a TownHall recently . . . he rambled for over 15 minutes and still never answered the question. But, I bet he and Biden have similar discussions . . . that only they understand.
    The Bamster is spending the US into 3rd world status. The debt clock is ticking . . . anyone watching Greece? California is already in worse shape than Greece, govt handouts will soon cease.
    The healthshare bill is nonsense . . . 16 thousand IRS agents to enforce it, building jungle jims and sidewalks, gutting Medicare and downloading Billions of costs to the states. Plus massive tax increases and fees. Check out Britain . . . this is the future!!

  • American Liberal

    As of yet, I haven’t heard that president Obama plans on granting amnasty … Something has to be done.. And the cold hard fact is the last administration neglected everything and now anything President Obama does is going to be opposed by the Anti everything not republican right.. My opinion is that the right screwed up this country so bad I don’t care what you think..and that’s been my biggest complaint about President Obama… Trying to please the right..they had their chance .. Look where they took the country…facism and debt…now they don’t like tax dollars being spent on America?.. I didn’t like my tax dollars spent on Bushs Iraq adventure… Nor do I likey tax dollar spent on isreal..we provide American dollars allover the world( socialism) but the rightwing doesn’t want Americans to benifit from healthcare ..that’s too bad..

    • angel-wanna-be

      Yeah right, Bush completely ignored the fact we were under attack on
      9/11 TOO__Keeping America and her people safe was a hell-of-alot more important than ANYTHING ELSE!___ If Al Quaida succeeded in taking out more Americans, ANYTHING Bush wanted to improve on would have been done for what reason?__If you don’t have a Country of people there’s nothing to govern!!!___First things first my friend!___Obama has done the same thing by placing a priority on healthcare, closing gitmo, breaking down our CIA, and pussyfying them into a more sensitve, politically correct agents, that mirandize terrorists on the fields and make sure there litte personalities are being treated fairly____Wall the while the economy is still in the tank and the private sector is still being nationalized__GIVE ME A FREAKIN’ BREAK LIB!!!

      • eyeswideopen

        angel, are you saying that all Bush did for 12 hours everyday was concentrate on the war? If that is all he did, how did the shoe bomber get into the country? Just wondering.

  • American Liberal

    Angel… What did George W.Bush do?… And Ehat did Ronsld Reagan do… ?…at least President Obama has the backbone to do something… Of course you won’t like it… You wouldn’t like anything he does…I’d at least like to know who and where the illegals are… What’s your solution?.. More nothing?

    • American Liberal

      Typo “what”

    • angel-wanna-be

      My first solution would be is to, put these 16,000 new IRS agents to work, not just enforcing healthcare insurance violators(because most of us have insurance at the moment) since they’re going to be brandishing shotguns anyway, let’s round up the illegalS, and profile them to find out if they’re legal or not!!__If the people they round up aren’t card carrying, them shippem’ the hell out of here, until they do it right!!___Just because Reagan or Bush didn’t bother with the illegals, doesn’t make me wanna jump up and down, now that Obama decides to do something about the illegals. “Whoop di sh*T!”__The economy is still in the tank, we going to be taxed out the ass, we still have the war__and_ Oh and BTW, healthcare won’t be available for at least another 4 years, TELL ME, DID THE PEOPLE STOP DYING IN THE STREETS SINCE HEALTHCARE REFORM PASSED??____ NOW,If you read or listen too, more than just the Liberal news media__you’d already know and understand, that allowing and influx of Illegals into the United States was/is already in the grand scheme of things. The savior will give the ILLEGALS freedom, that will add more to the dependent welfare trough, as a result, they will be forever grateful and vote for the one who set them free. OBAMA AND HIS BAND OF MERRY MEN, WON’T REST UNTIL AMERICA IS COMPLETEY SOCIALIZED!__If you wish to follow your shepherd, then by all means!!!!

      • http://?? Joe H.

        Angel,
        didn’t you hear??? Death took a long vacation……4 years!!! Whooo wooop!!!

  • Pat

    We need to enforce our immigration laws that we have already. Amnesty has been granted 7 times since 1986 and it has NOT helped our country. Yes we are a nation if Immigrants but most have come here LEGALLY! We keep rewarding these people who are breaking our laws, threatening our country’s Security. Yes some pay taxes (hopefully on their own SS) but they are costing the American taxpayers much more by using our hospitals for free, Medicaid, food stamps and WIC, anchor babies, which by the way was not meant to be used that way (read the column by George R. Will). They are bankrupting our country! The Drug lords are ruining the border towns and now it is spilling over into the rest of the US. When are we going to get wise? Probably never. Secure our borders for immigrants that came here the legal way.

    • American Liberal

      Pat… For a start we could do as suggest .. And I agree…if we enforced the laws aginst the businesses that hire illegals we wouldn’t be having this same discussion almost every decade…I believe the majority of the illegals were discussing are from Mexico that come here for jobs.. Correct?.. So if we enforced the law aginst hiring them I believe the majority would stop coming.. We have to many people on this side of the border encouraging them to come by offering them jobs.. Those people are the real guilty people.. That’s where we need to be tough..

  • angel-wanna-be

    The Dems forged ahead with Healthcare reform against the will of the people, they’ll do the same with amnesty program. Can anyone say Democratic votes??___The Dems are going to need all the votes they can get, come November and they know it!__
    ___Years ago my husband worked for a company, that when anyone who even looked like law enforcement, walked in the front door, half of the workers ran out the back door!__Unfortunately, Illegals are cheap labor, they will do the meager jobs alot of America won’t do. Whether illegal or American citizen, My guess is, if you get hungry enough, you’ll do what ever job it takes to feed yourself and/or your family.__At 53, Experience has show me, that you can only afford to be choosy is in, times of abundance.__None-the-less, like Moses parting the sea for his people to cross into the land flowing with milk and honey, Obama will completely open the borders, that America only half-assed patrolled and guarded anyway. While plenty of illegals are already here in the US, an influx of new Illegals should put the screws to America’s job-less-ness nicely and force more people to feed at Pharoah Obama’s welfare trough.
    This administration claims to wave the flag of truth, as the lies seep through their gnashing teeth. This pharoah needs to go in 2012 along with the rest of his elitest kingdom!

    • DamnYankee

      Truth is arguable-”the truth according to whoever is speaking” like global warming: facts are not-1+1 still equals 2 and 2+2 still equals four. Fact is we have millions of illegals. Fact is we have millions of unemployed or underemployed Americans. If you as an employer do not verify an alien, or knowingly hire an illegal, it is tantamount to treason and should be prosecuted as such. That they are seeking a better life—tell that to Texas, New Mexico, Arizon, California, or anywhere they are in great numbers.

  • Emma

    When immigration reform went down in June 2007, the unemplyment rate was about 5% so it is disingenuous to say that the current high unemployment rate is the problem.
    All of you who purport to be for enforcement of the immigration laws should support the implementation of a biometric tamper-proof social security card as suggested by Senators Schumer and Graham. The best way to curb illegal immigration is to make it extremely hard to work without authorization.

    • James

      Emma, I say the best way to control immigration is to enforce the immigration laws we have, and the way to do that is for the federal government to control who and what passes over our borders.

      • Harley

        James,

        I second that 100%. Also, I do not need a biometric card forced on me because we let people into our country illegally. There is a procedure for people to get into our country legally. These existing laws should be enforced. As well, letting people come in illegally is not fair to the people who do apply for legal entrance into the country.

      • American Liberal

        James… Wrong…the border isn’t the answer to stopping illegals… That’s putting a bandaid on a major operation … We need to work on why they come here…. If we enforced the laws aginst hiring illegals then their would be no reason for them to come… No fence is going to stop illegal immigrants… The fence is nonsence…you ever climb a fence as a kid?… It’s the greedy people looking to exploit them that are the problem… No jobs for illegals= no illegals… Or less illegals …

      • TIME

        Nano, This is a first I agree with you!

      • James

        American Liberal, I agree that The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 should be enforced. It essentially outlawed employment of illegal aliens, but our southern border needs to be defended against a continual invasion of more illegals. We are supposed to a nation of laws, not men. A nation that does not, or cannot, control who and what passes over its borders is no longer a nation.

      • American Liberal

        President Obama ran his campaign on the promise of healthcare refore… “We the people” elected him…. His pool numbers on healthcare are low because us liberals wanted the single payer option and we didn’t like that he kept bending over backwards trying to include republicans who’s only agenda is for him to fail…. I’m not worried about his polls… Ask me right before the next presidential election.. Right now The Presidents polls are similar to Ronald Reagans at the sametime… No worries …

      • TIME

        Nano,
        Thats not quite right dude. As a matter of fact BarryO’s numbers are very low due to the fact that 70%+ of the US population that “pays tax’s” did not, nor do they want the HCR bill that was passed.

        Thats the facts that even MSNBC could not hide. Even try as they may
        with polls taken in as deep of pockets as they could get of the entitlements crew. They even know its going to cost them money!

      • zack

        Obam-bams health care reform is going down the pupe shoot. It is out of here, no go ro-ho, failed, democrats backing up, changing their minds, bad deal they say, zilt, quit. Re-think or our a$$ is out of here in NOVEMBER. The idiots are finally getting the message. Americans do not want it. Keep the pressure on AMERICANS and they will flush it soon. Mark my word.

      • eyeswideopen

        Haley, we presently give them Green cards, what is the big deal in changing the type of cards? All visitors, with visa’s should be identified and available in our system. You are aware that almost every state has a requirement that if you don’t have a driver’s license, you must have a state ID card to be able for the police, hospitals to identify you, aren’t you? You have probably always had a drivers lic. so you don’t know about the state ID cards.

    • DamnYankee

      Who gets the biometric, tamper-proof ID, them or us, accorging to the proposed Schumer-Graham law?

  • Americal Liberal

    I’ve got to give President Obama credit for taking on an issue that was ignored for over a decade ( especially ignored by republicans)…President Reagan granted amnasty when he was president and everything was Ok with conservatives then… What needs to be done is finally have a policy that we follow towards immigrants… I believe to many business owners are only to happy to just keep turning a blind eye and employing ” illegals ” as cheap labor.. Exploiting humanbeings…if we are going to have undocumented people working here let’s change that and document them and get them working in the system and paying taxes… The villian?.. The people hiring the illegals just for cheap labor.. This hurts both the American workers and the undocumented… Let’s get everybody out in the open..

    • TIME

      Nano Wit,
      “Exploitation” is on both sides of this issue, don’t kid yourself.

      In New York where the cost of living is near the level of insane, as in our home just sold for what can be noted as Crazy money even in a good market. let alone todays market.
      Be that as it may – an 800 Sqft appartment on Long Island rents for $2500.00 – $3900.00 per month, keep in mind these are not legal appartments these are underground basements, sheds, above stores etc..
      Yea what about that, people have to do this to pay their property TAXS. Again – thats crazy, average taxs around the North Shore are $30K per year and three and four times that amount in many places on the North shore.

      There are many Mexicans living in these appartments, as many as 6 or 10 in 800 SQft.
      Where do they work local restaurants, stores, gas stations, and they work for “CASH only,” they don’t want to be legal.

      This saves the owners money by not paying – Social Security, Unemployment Insurance, Health Insurance, and IRS Tax’s, just to name a few, so whos being exploited.

      I have a Mexican friend there who is citizen of the US and has been for twenty years, he can’t get a job due to his being a US citizen nor can any of his other Mexican friends that are legal.
      He came to me with a strong business plan, I gave him money to start up his Restaurant – I am happy to say – he is doing very well.
      Now before you tell me how I am taking advantage of him, please note I said I gave him the money, its not a loan.

      You really need to get out more and stop watching Katie Quackie, and all the Wacko’s on the standard media.

      I don’t think anyone should be a slave, but on that note the majority are not here legaly. Thus a Federal crime, as in the law has been broken.
      By the way just for the record, Food stamps and other aid is flowing to these people by the way of FRAUD from groups like Acorn.

    • James

      American Liberal, President Reagan did no such thing. He may have favored amnesty but he didn’t grant it. Our presidents are not kings, the Executive Branch of government simply executes the laws of the Legislative Branch (Congress). The only way illegal aliens could get amnesty, is for Congress to amend our immigration laws and create an exception, in it, for them. However, even this would be an unconstitutional retroactive law.

      • eyeswideopen

        James, you are wrong. Reagan signed The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986. http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/1008amnesty-intro.html

      • James

        Eyeswideopen, The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 didn’t grant amnesty to illegal aliens, it basically outlawed their employment here. Title I, Sec. 101. Control of unlawful employment of aliens, reads: “It is unlawful for a person or other entity to hire…for employment in the United States…an alien knowing the alien is an unauthorized alien…with respect to such employment.” Sec. 103 outlawed the “misuse of certain immigration related documents,” by illegal aliens. This referred to the phony citizenship certificates that were in use. This Act says nothing about amnesty, it was effort to make employment of illegal aliens more difficult.

      • eyeswideopen

        James, just for you, http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1065553/posts

        Since when did you think the gov would use hot words like “amnesty” in it’s laws?? LMAO, you know better than that. Read article to end, you will enjoy it as you are a literal person.

      • James

        Eyeswideopen, The law means what it says, not what people want it to mean. There are congressmen who want amnesty for illegals, but so far no amnesty has been granted to them.

      • James

        Eyeswideopen, Your article isn’t the law. What someone writes about it doesn’t alter what the law says. The article’s mention of ‘amnesty’ has confused you. The Act in question criminalized the employment of illegal aliens, it did not make them citizens with rights, if it had, the Act itself would have been unconstitutional.

      • eyeswideopen

        James, you can’t read, I posted exactly what the law reads, section, by section. You just want to deny it. Typical RWA stance. You radicals won’t accept a law that is in black and white, if you don’t like it. Dude, just accept fact law is 64 years old and Obama didn’t write it. Stop the fear mongering,

      • eyeswideopen

        James, I know you trust fox news so here is their link, please notice they use word amnesty. lol http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,122297,00.html

      • James

        Eyeswideopen, Foxnews.com said: “the 1986 immigration reforms…show just how damaging another illegal immigration amnesty would be to our country.” I quoted from that law, just above. Foxnews was just saying how damaging amnesty would be to our country. Their word “another” may have confused you, it suggests aamnesty has been granted, when it clearly has not. Do a search for: “The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986″, and click on a site that displays that law. You will find that my quotes are accurate. That Act did not grant amnesty, nor has it ever been granted, it simply criminalized employment of illegals, the purpose being to discourage more aliens from coming here illegally to seek work.

      • eyeswideopen
      • James

        Eyeswideopen, Your “law is 64 years old” statement would refer to a law enacted in 1946, and your “hotair.com” source said: “Error 404 – Not Found” and displayed nothing. You are simply refusing to face the facts, if the Democrats are now proposing that amnesty be extended to illegals, why would they bother if it had already happened?

    • David

      American Gliberal, you’re WRONG. It wasn’t Ok when Regan did it and all it did was to increase the flow of criminal across the border. It doesn’t matter if they work hard or pay taxes (most don’t as they can’t show anything but stolen or fabricated SSN’s; i.e. FELONY Identity theft). Every ¢ they make is a crime and theft from US citizens. Every time an employer pays them 1¢ s/he too commits a crime. All they do is drive down wages, cost the rest of us in “free” services and social programs, drunk driving deaths and accidents, property crimes and loss of jobs that citiznes would otherwise do at legal, living wages.

      • James

        David, President Reagan didn’t sign a bill into law, that granted amnesty to illegal aliens. You are being misled by other’s comments. Read my above response to Eyeswideopen, and do a search for that 1986 law yourself. You are right that that law didn’t stop the flow of illegals, but it was because U.S. employers ignored that law and hired illegals anyway.

  • Amy007

    this is so not true. The undocumented workers are already here and have jobs, so they won’t compete with Americans for new jobs. Many of them pay taxes and are hard working people. Many have husbands/wives who are either US citizens or permanent residents and they need to get the chance to adjust their status! Why do we want to ruin peoples’ lives? Aren’t we a country of immigrants? Not doing anything will harm us even more. In ten years we will have 20 million of undocumented workers because if the law is not reformed our own greedy employers will hire those people. What are we going to do with 20 million people ? Avoiding to solve this problem is irresponsible, and ruining peoples’ lives is immoral. Schumer-Graham bill is very good and the biometric ID and E-verify should solve the problem or at least slow it down significantly. Those who oppose the reform most likely benefit from the current situation and the illegal workers.

    • Americal Liberal

      Good post Amy.. I agree and you said it well..

      • http://?? Joe H.

        Yeah, and once you take 12 to 30 million illegals off the workforce, 12 to 30 million American workers (U.S. type) will be able to return to work!!!!

    • Cribster

      There’s a balance to every thing, when you help illegal aliens you hurt American citizens.

      There is way beyond 20 million now and it’s due to the amnesty in 1986, when you reward bad behavior you get more bad behavior.

      Thousands of innocent American citizens have been slaughtred by illegal aliens. Here’s just one place to see a fraction of the horrors.

      I’ve seen the destruction first hand. In a ten year period I saw a neighborhood go from 15% hispanic to 95% and anyone that is not hispanic is not welcome there. Diversity? they’ll laugh in your face, that is if they even understand you. That area now looks like ancient Aztek.

      They are bankrupting hospitals and destroying our education system.

      They have no respect for America and it’s citizens. How anyone can just surrender the sovereignty of our nation is beyond me. This is an invasion the likes of which man-kind has never seen!

      We can rid ourselves of this plague. Enforce the laws on the books! Stop coddlilng the invaders and end sanctuary cities. No more birthright citizenship, that’s just insane. Implement e-verify nationwide. Install a complete Iraeli style fence, they work!!

      We need to make life miserable for illegals rather than Americans.

      • Cribster

        Excuse me, forgot the link;

        http://www.ojjpac.org/memorial.asp

      • Michelle

        Well said. Anyone that is for amnesty is just listening to the propaganda of how “these poor people are just looking to make a better life.” Well, try living in Arizona! They have destroyed the schools, hospitals and neighborhoods. The school my kids went to, which at the time had a very low hispanic attendance is now 75% hispanic. Surrounding schools are facing even higher percentages. This is all taking away from the education of our children! They work under the table and don’t pay taxes – I’ve seen it! Try finding a job if you don’t speak Spanish. Local signs are only posted in Spanish – NO ENGLISH! That is only the tip of what is happening. People should be allowed to immigrate to the US but under legal conditions. Rewarding illegal actions over and over again is only helping perpetuate the problem.

    • James

      Amy007, We are a country of laws, not men. When aliens enter our illegally, they become criminals. Rewarding that criminal action with citizenship and rights is tantamount to treason. When an American citizen entered North Korea illegally, he was arrested, tried, convicted and sentenced to 18 years of hard labor there. I’m not suggesting we do likewise, but entering our country illegally is a crime. If that isn’t punished to some extent, and is even rewarded, it sends a loud and clear wrong signal to the world. A nation that control who and what passes over its borders is no longer sovereign.

    • Jeep

      Amy, do not let any facts get in the way of your compassion. Such as, according to the Center for Immigrations Studies, “A 1997 study by the American Academy of Sciences found that the cheap labor of illegal immigrants and poor immigrants caused a 44% decrease in wages among the poorest Americans from 1980 to 1994.” Or, this crazy non-sense, “Amnesty for illegal immigrants will cause costs to increase significantly from $10.4 billion a year to $28.8 billion. This is because an amnesty program would transform an illegal immigrant to an “unskilled immigrant with legal status” who could access various government programs. However, due to low income, these “unskilled immigrants with legal status” would likely make very modest tax payments.”

      But, of course, all illegals are just here to work, right? However, ” Illegal immigrants collectively represent a group that is a significant menace to the public. 80% have committed serious crimes in addition to immigration violations, and 40% have violent crime histories.”

    • Butler

      Blah Blah Blah. Yes we are a nation if Immigrants but most have come here LEGALLY! We keep rewarding these people who are breaking our laws, threatening our country’s Security. Yes some pay taxes (hopefully on their own SS) but they are costing the American taxpayers much more by using our hospitals for free, Medicaid, food stamps and WIC, anchor babies, which by the way was not meant to be used that way (read the column by George R. Will). They are bankrupting our country! The Drug lords are ruining the border towns and now it is spilling over into the rest of the US. When are we going to get wise? Probably never. Secure our borders for immigrants that came here the legal way. This is so so true. Wake up America. Feeling sorry for “Criminals” has to stop. Even legals get fake papers to scam the system.

    • Stephen G. Browning

      You said ” Why do we want to ruin peoples’ lives? Aren’t we a country of immigrants?”. That statment is so true and the lives that it will ruin are the people that fought for their life. You don’t see the whole picture. Get some glasses, please.

    • Regina

      I hate to inform you of this Amy but we already do have 20,000,000 ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS living here. They are not undocumented workers. They broke a law to get here. Why don’t you tell the “they just come here looking for a better life” to the family of the Arizona farmer who was just murdered on his own land by more “undocumented workers” looking for a better life. Why don’t you tell that to the families of the 4 children who were killed on a school bus in Minnesota by an “undocumented worker” looking for a better life. Why don’t you tell that to Callie Jo Larsons mother. She was the 12 year old girl who was raped, murdered and hung from the rafters of her home at 4:00 pm in the afternoon by your “undocumented worker looking for a better life”.

      • Claire

        Regina– Good for you. Well said.

    • DamnYankee

      Since the government won’t do anything for the unemployed or underployed Americans, the individual needs to ask for verification thay they are here legally, or not hire the individual or boycott the company that hires them. I, for one, would not hire them, or use a company that does. (i.e. roofing, cement work, etc). I saw what happened when a bunch was hired to reroof homes after an ice storm. They have no idea how to reroof a house. The insurance companies will not pay a second or third time, that I KNOW.

    • DamnYankee

      Why should our education system be “dumb-down” (less then mediocure)just for them? American children are not taught what they need to be taught. We must not offend or be “politically correct”. Why should the taxpayer pay for their food stamps, medicad, or hostipal bill? Why should some be able to abuse people or their property, and the authorities can’t do anything, unless someone is murdered? Much of our prison population are illegals. The prison population would be much more if all could or would be caught. How do think much of the illegal drugs get here? Yes, Americans, (who don’t think what drugs can do) are the consumers, but think how much better we would be if illegal drugs were no here.

    • Palin12

      Amy, don’t you know that referring to illegal aliens as “undocumented workers” is like referring to drug dealers as “undocumented pharmacists”?

    • David

      Amy, WHAT are you SMOKING!!!! These people are criminals: C-R-I-M-I-N-A-L-S

    • http://None Robert Samuel

      Some people want to act as there are no immigration laws.
      One thing that is never talked about, the law states how many people
      can enter the United States a year, and we have been leaving more
      than is allowed, and it has to come to a stop. Experts on this subject have said the immigration department will never be able to handle millions of people, and this is going to cost trillions of
      dollars over ten years. When are we going to start to bring the depth
      down?

blog comments powered by Disqus
Bottom