Comments Subscribe to Personal Liberty Digest™ News Feed Subscribe to Personal Liberty Digest™ 

Republicans Threaten To Skip Healthcare Summit Unless Obama Starts From Scratch

February 12, 2010 by  

Republicans threaten to skip healthcare summit unless Obama starts from scratchOn Monday, leading House Republicans responded to President Obama’s proposal for a bipartisan summit on healthcare reform, stating that they may decline to participate if the administration uses the Democratic bills as a starting point.

In a letter to White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-Ohio) and Minority Whip Eric Cantor (R-Va.) expressed concern over reports that the president plans to promote the same piece of legislation that the GOP has publicly condemned over the last few months.

"If the starting point for this meeting is the job-killing bills the American people have already soundly rejected, Republicans would rightly be reluctant to participate," Boehner and Cantor wrote.

The two House leaders also openly questioned Obama’s sincerity regarding an open, bipartisan discussion concerning healthcare reform.

"’Bipartisanship’ is not writing proposals of your own behind closed doors, then unveiling them and demanding Republican support," they said. "Bipartisan ends require bipartisan means."

In response, White House press secretary Robert Gibbs said that the president is open to any "good ideas that stand up to objective scrutiny," but also stated that Obama has been clear about his support for the congressional bills created by Democrats.
ADNFCR-1961-ID-19606559-ADNFCR

Personal Liberty News Desk

Facebook Conversations

Join the Discussion:
View Comments to “Republicans Threaten To Skip Healthcare Summit Unless Obama Starts From Scratch”

Comment Policy: We encourage an open discussion with a wide range of viewpoints, even extreme ones, but we will not tolerate racism, profanity or slanderous comments toward the author(s) or comment participants. Make your case passionately, but civilly. Please don't stoop to name calling. We use filters for spam protection. If your comment does not appear, it is likely because it violates the above policy or contains links or language typical of spam. We reserve the right to remove comments at our discretion.

Is there news related to personal liberty happening in your area? Contact us at newstips@personalliberty.com

  • papajoe

    If you do not listen to the public and do their will then the public will replace you. We have had enough of the closed door meetings and the bribes so what we demand and I repeat demand is something we can live with. Robbing our children and grandchildren of the America we grew up with is unaccetable.
    Let’s make sure we go to the polls and vote our Conscience.

  • Raggs

    I’m glad to see the GOP sound off, in reality though obama will never back down from a complete takeover. Remember he is a marxist and he bow’s to communist.

  • Jeanne

    If any GOP believes Obamacare will become law, it’s because they know the Dems are going to use reconciliation regardless of any dog/pony show!!! Dems have already proven they will get it through by hook or by crook!

  • Jeanne

    GOP has a valid point, there’s no reason to meet over a bill we, the american public don’t want. Obama seems determined to turn it into a dog/pony show to sway us to revive his fiasco health care bill written to favor insurance/drug companies (and addresses only availability).

    Real Health Care Reform is about COSTS!!! Lower costs will increase availability. Tort reform, sell insurance across states (competition favors the consumer) and mandate pharmacueticals stop gouging America by ratcheting up their prices to us. The world is using the same drug, why is America only one funding their research, rofl.

    There’s NO EXCUSE to allow insurance/drug companies to continue gouging us (Obamacare would encourage that to continue since it doesn’t address costs). Obama is acting like a “ruler” not a leader by insisting to pass a flawed health care bill we don’t want! I’m sick of his lies and digs at GOP.

  • http://www.thesubstratum.com GJMerits

    For those who may have forgot, it was McConnell and Cornyn’s strategy to have ObamaCare pass in an effort to increase mid-term gains. In short – sell out the country for power.

    Read: http://www.politico.com/news/stories/1209/30869.html

    “After weeks of refusing to embrace the “obstructionist” label as a virtue, Senate Republicans finally saw the light and late last week began to use the parliamentary tools at their disposal to delay a final vote on health care.

    Until then, with the exception of South Carolina Sen. Jim DeMint, Republican lawmakers had refused to use Senate rules and procedures to obstruct the passage of the health care bill being pushed by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and run out the clock on Obamacare. Some prominent Republican senators and members of their staffs had even let it be known they actually believed passage of the Reid health care bill and enactment of Obamacare would benefit GOP candidates in the November midterm elections.

    This GOP strategy of expedient complicity enraged the conservative base, roused talk radio show hosts and bloggers and even provoked a backlash from the chairman of the Republican National Committee. The Social Security Institute and the National Tax Limitation Committee joined with Tea Party Support and Gun Owners of America to convey this outrage to the Senate Republican leadership through letters, e-mails and telephone calls from the grass roots to GOP senators’ offices. ”

    Here is the email creative text that turned the tide and exposed the strategy, forcing the GOP to change its tune:

    “Republican Senator John Cornyn, the man charged with taking back control of the United States Senate for Republicans issued a memo to his colleagues and candidates Saturday suggesting that if the Democratic health care reform bill becomes law, it will be to the GOP’s political advantage.

    The Senate Republican Leadership Does Not Get It – OR Worse – Does Not Care about this country and only cares about THEIR JOBS!

    A few GOP Senators, however, are willing to stand in the gap with Senator Jim DeMint and Michael Steele and obstruct, obstruct, obstruct. The Forces of Obstruction are advancing but time is short and a Democratic blitzkrieg counterattack is about to begin.

    Republican National Chairman Michael Steele understands this simple truth and has joined you in the fight to demand that Republican Senators obstruct, obstruct, obstruct and kill the Reid Bill.

    THE GOOD NEWS IS each Senator (Without Approval from Leadership) has the power to stop this rush to judgment. Any Senator who refuses to use that power will be complicit; will be responsible for enacting ObamaCare into law. Tell them you will vote against their re-election if they fail to JUST OBJECT.”

    It almost looks like the GOP is up to its old games. The price will be very, very heavy if they screw this up, attend, and in any way advance the agenda of ObamaCare.

    • JeffH

      A politician is a politician and it makes no differance what coat they wear. It make for a better understanding of the growing Tea Party movement in America.

    • L, USA

      Are you Nancy Pelosi?

    • Meteorlady

      Excuse me but……. John Cornyn is my Senator and has NEVER endorse government run health care. In fact, all the letters that I have received from him is very straight and to the point – he does not support it. I also note that in the article you reference there was no mention of Cornyn. He is one of the few Senators that I would vote for again as he always represents his district and the people that elected him.

    • Joe H.

      GJMerits,
      Excuse me for asking, but what power did the Republicans have before Sen. Browns election? The Dems had a super majority and had no power what so ever!!!

  • http://www.personalliberty.com Wildcat from Dallastown, PA

    I think now is the time for the conservatives to stand up and vigorously present the strong and logical case of starting from square one on actual, meaningful, health care reform with the alternative of announcing to the people that we only had one item to compromise on which Obama has refused thereby removing any remote concept of bipartisanship involvement. It’s about time the Republican leadership takes the wood to the “Pirates on the Potomac” armed with the will of the citizens they represent; nothing partisan about that. Regardless of the lame response, if any, is rendered by Barry and his boys, perhaps the Republican leadership should respond by email with an embedded link to a professionally produced presentation clearly articulating the will of the people based upon campaign promises versus documented violations and the peoples’ total and absolute resolve stop their policies and remove them from office coordinated with a release of same to Fox News, Rush Limbaugh and his stand in hosts’ shows, (and slightly later to the lamestream media).

    I can’t take the credit for developing that glorious piece of truly patriotic work, but I will provide to all of you to view and enjoy and determine for yourselves if this doesn’t capture your thoughts. Your attention is invited to: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0bh77kWdk. An administrative note here, you will want to turn your speakers UP for this one! If you have you computer connected to a powerful theater surround sound system you would think you have just witnessed the movie premier to the most action packed political thriller ever produced. That is unless you are one of the members of the pirate ship commanded by the “Pirates on the Potomac”, and then you will be justifiably scared for your continued political career.

    The Republicans in the Senate and the House have to be on the same page with their message to the President and the people.

    The only aspect of any currently proposed forms have that reflect one of the points of contention with health insurance providers (and not the health care they receive) is the removal of the pre-existing conditions clause. ALL remaining aspects of the existing proposals are pure pieces of excrement designed to remove you of as many personal liberties and freedoms as possible and transfer those to the federal government.

    I would like to add the following relative to the definition of bipartisanship as what representation will be EXCLUDED without fail. SEIU/ACORN and the auto workers union representatives are not part of anything resembling a bipartisan effort.

  • http://www.thesubstratum.com GJMerits

    Obstructionism in defense of liberty is no vice and cooperation in pursuit of tyranny is no virtue.

    If the GOP attends the summit and anything resembling ObamaCare passes of anything providing for a Trojan horse for a government takeover or a government backed insurance cartel takeover of our healthcare subsequently passes, the GOP attendance will be scored by us as a vote for ObamaCare.

    I submit the following if ObamaCare passes subsequent to the meeting (the following scores apply to the GOP):

    The meeting will take place at a round table with no teleprompters allowed. If this agreement is not accepted the meeting is off. Failure to secure this agreement prior to the meeting will be scored as a vote for ObamaCare.

    The President and Democrats in both Houses have already said they will not start over. More to the point a Politico story states that “Obama hopes to walk into the Feb. 25 summit with an agreement in hand between House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid on a final Democratic bill, so they can move ahead with a reform package after the sit-down.” The House GOP must make this an issue and call out the President on the false premise of the entire event. If agreement is reached on a final bill, what is the purpose of the meeting? Where is the bi-partisanship if the bill was agreed to a priori to the event? Failure to do so will be scored as a vote for ObamaCare.

    The President stated that reconciliation will not be taken off the table. As this amounts to shoving an unpopular bill down American’s throats and trampling on minority rights in the Senate, the entire premise of the summit is again called into question and the President’s real agenda for the meeting exposed. The House GOP must challenge the President on this point. Failure to do so will be scored as a vote for ObamaCare.

    The House GOP must insist they be able to invite House Democrats opposed to the measure. If they are not allowed to do so, the meeting is over. Failure of the House GOP to insist upon this provision will be scored as a vote for ObamaCare.

    The House GOP must be allowed to invite officials and lawmakers from those states that has passed or are working on passing legislation/resolutions challenging the constitutionality of the individual mandate. Failure of the House GOP to insist upon this provision will be scored as a vote for ObamaCare.

    The House GOP must be allowed to invite their own experts, including but not limited to actuaries from the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and members from the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office. Failure of the House GOP to insist upon this provision will be scored as a vote for ObamaCare.

    Again, whether the GOP attends or not, the liberal media are going to spin, spin, spin. This “summit” is a disaster in the making; we have everything to lose and nothing to gain. Obama, Pelosi, and Reid have dug a deep hole, jumped in and are now extending their hands for our assistance in extricating them out of a disaster of their own making. If Republicans help revive this bill, they will lose a number of us out here in the voting world. I fear going to this summit will be a turning point.

  • Nadia

    Hoepfully the republicans will stand on principle and not be deceived by this trojan horse obama with some phony bipartisan tv show.
    This sudden transparency is an insult to every American’s intellegence.

    I would like to see obama removed from office for not upholding the constitution of the USA.
    Nadia

  • http://Hubpages.com Ralph Deeds

    More mischief from the party of NO. Boehner is a sleazy lounge lizard. Gingrich is worse. He’s done a complete reversal of his earlier positions advocating huge cuts in Medicare. Their proposals as expressed by Congressman Paul Ryan are disingenuous because ultimately they would dismantle Social Security and Medicare.

    • JeffH

      Ralph Deeds, do you support the Democrat Health Care Bill proposal?
      Just thought I would ask.

    • DaveH

      Social Security and Medicare are going to be dismantled by the Democrat impoverishment of our country.

    • Joe H.

      Ralph,
      He might be underhanded but right now I like the way he’s talking!!

  • J C

    This is without a doubt the sneakiest most underhanded (so called)President in history. Besides this great drive for life anbd death control of American Health Care, BHO is trying to fly the re enactment of the (anti) Patriot Act under the radar. While everyone is focused on the Health care debacle….sneaky sneaky sneaky…RAT!

  • Norm

    House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-Ohio) and Minority Whip Eric Cantor (R-Va.) are total obstructionists and very unsavory charactors. There is nothing that Obama could suggest, even some of their own few ideas, that they would agree with.
    I personally think that the Democratic plan(s) leave a lot to be desired. I’m glad to see that they haven’t passed in their present form.
    We certainly need tort reform, freedom to buy drugs from wherever they are cheapest, true competition within the insurance cartel, rules governing insurance policies, and mandatory coverage for all. We all(even the GOP) know the present system is inefficient, incredibly expensive, and unsustainable over time. One major Insurance company just increased rates by more than 30% this year while inflation was less than 2%.
    Boehner and Cantor are hell bent on creating gridlock in healthcare, jobs creation, and any and everything proposed by the Dems. This is not what they were elected to do.
    Differences of opinion are definately needed in a Democracy. but doing nothing for political reasons only, is wrong.

    • http://www.citizenforfreedom.blogspot.com JOSEPH LARSON

      Norm, I agree there is a lot of “just” politics in what they are doing. But, if they do not hold the line right now, you will never see, tort reform, international availability of drugs, true competition from insurance companies and foremost, you will see Obama back for a second term. Why would anyone who is an American citizen want a guy who on nation TV. stated, He and his wife had attended flag burnings, AMERICAN FLAG BURNINGS, why would they want a President who refuses to follow protocol when the National Anthem is played. He stated, he did not want to appear to take sides. That is why he did not wear an American Flag pin when he actually attended congressional meetings. He want to change our flag, it needs to give hope to our enemies. HIS WORDS NOT MINE. Norm, do you not get it. He is anti-american, he does not have the best interest of this country at heart, he has done everything he can to grease the downhill slide of our economy and created division of our people. It is not bad judgement, it is not bad advisors, it is not ignorance. It is intentional with one goal in mind. DESTROY THIS NATION. HE HATES AMERICA, WHAT HE IS DOING IS A HATE CRIME.

      • Norm

        JOSEPH LARSON
        I have to disagree with you.
        I think Obama is doing a good job at a very difficult time. He did not create this mess. The economy exploded before he even took office.
        What he needs now is all the help and brain power he can muster. What he’s getting from the Dems. is discussion and action, unfortunatly most of it is for personal political posturing with little real concern for the US. What he’s getting from the Reps. is nothing but venom, hate, and foot dragging, in an attempt to discredit him. Our enemies must be delighted to see a badly divided and ill functioning America.
        If the government were a private corporation, non-team players could simply be fired and replaced with reliable, capable individuals. The government doesn’t have that luxury.
        With regard to Obama’s reelection: If it were held today, even at this bottoming of the economy, he would surely be elected. He has no competition. All the polls show he is ahead of a generic Republican, and any of the so called top contenders.

      • CS Key

        Do you ever wonder why the first “revolution” since the break from England is occuring again as I write this? Why are you saying “hatred for Obama” when you should be saying, “hatred for who he is and how he acts”. When everything we stand for, as Americans, is being destroyed before our eyes you have to think that something more is happening than mere “hatred”. Lots of people disliked Nixon, and certainly Clinton was immoral, but nothing approaches the rebellion we are seeing today.

        Maybe the very core of our existence is at stake, and our children and grandchildren will suffer for what we did…if we don’t say “STOP” and “STOP NOW”! Look at my last name and try and remember who wrote our national anthem. I am extremely patriotic and I think the rest of America is “remembering” under duress and under the most inappropriate president to ever hold the office, what it is to BE AN AMERICAN.

        It is time to stand up and be counted among the ones who care and can see the bigger picture. Please don’t rail at the insurance companies…it is time for all of us to take responsibility for our actions including our health (or lack of it). Thanks for reading!

      • Meteorlady

        Norm – go here:

        http://www.gop.gov/solutions/healthcare

        Then go here:

        http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/blogs/beltway-confidential/CBO-Prepublican-health-plan-would-reduce-premiums–69270747.html

        The republicans have put forth numerous ideas but none have been publicized by mainstream media. I particularly like the last link – it says the Republican plan would indeed reduc e the deficity and decrease premiums.

      • Joe H.

        Norm,
        Why don’t you address the other points that are stated above? IE the fact that Obummer doesn’t cover his heart when the anthem is played, He isw unAmerican??

      • Norm

        Joe H.
        You call the elected president of the United States Obummer. Isn’t that unamerican? At best, it’s rude and hateful.

      • jeffH

        Gee whiz, Norm. Weren’t you one of the main contriutors to that book!

    • JeffH

      Norm, it is a shock to see you agreeing with your conservative counterparts,. Thank you for that.
      Blast the Republicans all you want, I don’t think they have a lot of support either. What they have done is listen to the “voices of America” and resisted Obama’s agenda to destroy America. They should at least be commended for protecting America from the evil forces, Democrats and the Obama Administration.
      If Obama can’t accept a fresh start on this issue, then like the Republicans, I say NO!

    • marvin

      just what would you do they are don,t what the people have said, no more lie,s and half truth and back room deals

    • eyeswideopen

      Hands clapping.

      • Joe H.

        Eyes,
        Typical that you would clap for that it doesn’t make any sense!!! Like I said earlier, hands clapping and brain ratteling!!!!

      • jeffH

        JoeH…talk about confused? Expected!

      • eyeswideopen

        Joe, that’s cause you didn’t read it, or comphrend it, one or the other. Not my fault.

    • DaveH

      “true competition within the insurance cartel, rules governing insurance policies, and mandatory coverage for all”

      How can we expect true competition if we are forced to buy health insurance? And how can we expect true competition if government dictates what their policies should contain. Actually the latter is already in place in many states which is one of the reasons that insurance is expensive. If Government would butt out, the companies would offer tailored plans, some of which would contain fewer exclusions and be more expensive, and some of which would have more exclusions but be cheaper. Then people could choose which they wanted to go with.
      So, your plan to make things cheaper is to pay more Government regulators to interfere with our health care choices. I thought you Liberals were always whining about “choice”. I guess that only applies to unborn children?
      And where do you, a Liberal, get off trying to force people to buy a product? I thought you guys were the ones who railed about the Big Bad Companies? So then you turn around and try to force us to buy their Products. You’re amazing, Norm.

      The Republicans are actually living up to their Constitutional Oaths unlike the law-breaking Democrats.

      • Norm

        DaveH
        The problem is that you and I could live with little or no government rules, regulations or social programs. Others, perhaps the majority of Americans, can not.
        One of the reasons that healthcare costs are so high is that the payers, insured or self funded, have to pay for themselves and all the non payers.
        If everyone was like me(and you?), we would not need locks on doors, police forces, judges and the expensive legal system, jails, medicaid, non refundable student loans and all the rest. Everyone is not like that unfortunately.
        If we didn’t have forced participation in the social security and medicare programs, you would have millions of destitude old people begging in the streets. People without the foresight to take care of their own affairs. At least, with the present system, most of these folks were forced to kick cash into the system for their own elderly care costs. Social Security is only taxed for the first $100K(or so) of income, so it is not the rich who are finiancing it. Also SS has been a profit center for the government not a loss. It’s taken in more than a trillion dollars than it has spent since it’s inception. The fact this money was wasted on other government priorities is shameful.

      • DaveH

        Norm,
        Then I guess the main difference between you and me is that I have faith that my fellow citizens would learn to take care of themselves if they weren’t given the illusion of a safety net. I say illusion, because SS premiums don’t go into a trust fund. As fast as government gets the receipts, they pay them back out to somebody else. In other words, a Ponzi Scheme. And it will fail some day.
        When we treat people like children, they will behave like children. Witness Tim’s comments.
        If you want a window to reality, just observe how teens behave until they get out of the house and have to pay their own way. Suddenly, they become decent human beings.
        If we got the government out of our everyday lives, our economy would be so robust, that charity would have no trouble caring for the few people who really did suffer misfortune through no fault of their own.

      • George

        Yes. Government needs to stick with those things that it can do best like providing national defense to protect the country from foreign enemies, enforcing law and order at home to keep the peace, providing a legal structure that helps markets work more productively in an open and competitive environment, providing a national currency and ensuring it doesn’t lose its value, etc. It needs to stay out of any business that can be served by private industries in a competitive environment.

      • Joe H.

        Norm,
        If the government was truly worried about the elders, they wouldn’t have raided the fund like they have over the years. The fund is almost bankrupt now and all they do is things that make less go into the fund!!! They talk health care first and jobs second. JOBS will put more into the fund Health care won’t!! The fund had a balance of well over 13 billion a scant 10 years ago and now it’s almost broke?!?!!?? Yeah, they’re really worried about the elderly!!!!

      • eyeswideopen

        JoeH, who had control a scant 10 years ago? NO, say it ain’t so Joe!!!

      • Doug

        Oh eyes and in your thought process that would be becasue of the administation that was in office before that! Wake the(word removed for offensive content) up both parties are screwing us there are liberals in each and every party, acutally in reality there is no difference the are playing for the same master behind the curtin!

  • Kris

    They need to watch what the other hand is doing while his mouth is moving! They are going to ram this down our throats using the 51 member vote while the republicans are talking in a room! I say nobama needs this bill so he can collect more power to control us! That is what this is, a power grab, nothing more. Does anyone think for 1 minute the messiah gives a rats ass about anyone but himself and his “family”? He wants power and then more power, hence the take overs of major industries, banks, utilities, etc. This deathcare bill will allow him to cull the population
    under the guise of the law, denying care to elderly, the handicapped and the “ones” he considers inferior to himself! How long are we the people, going to put up with this traitor? When will someone with some kahunas start the impeachment procedure? If they don’t then we must! This country is at stake and I for one, don’t want to lose our freedom! The so called “jobs bill” contains very little pertaining to jobs, it does however, contain pork and the extension of the patriot act. nobama said yesterday the Americans have no right to expect privacy with their phones and conversations! WHAT!!!!! Repub. Grassley signed onto this bill so now nobama can say, it was partisan! Grassly must go in November along with McCain, Graham, Snowe and others who cave to the almighty!!!!!

  • dennis thompson

    Republicans need to wake up too. We do not need any government run healthcare.
    We can not afford it.

  • Ann

    The Repblicans need to BE the party of NO with this administration. In over a year, nothing Obama-Pelosi-Reid have come up with would benefit this country. Obama is a professional liar, manipulator, and possibly hypnotist. The farther they stay away from him the better. Push-back is needed daily from the Republicans and November 2010 will be their reward. Obama is in the deep, dark pit and they need to stay away from the edges lest they be sucked in.

  • http://www.easyinvest.co.za pete

    How can the people of the USA accept flotus saying she hates America? and Obama is open to “good ideas that stand up to objective scrutiny”.
    That is the same as saying ” I am the boss and do as I say or else.
    That guy is a fake and should be incarcerated for impersonating a president.

  • Susan

    Dom T: I agree with most of what you have written, however, I refuse to purchase any insurance that the federal government is forcing on me. A couple of issues: The Feds have no business having access to my bank account (it’s in the bill) and I will not be forced to purchase anything that our “leaders” have exempt themselves from (it’s in the bill) and last but certainly not least: The Federal Government cannot force it’s citizens to purchase anything; it’s unconstitutional. While this so called president ignores our constitutional rights, he may be surprised how many citizens do not.

  • shirley Freeland

    I agree that the Republicans should not meet with Obama about healthcare if he doesn’t start over. They need to be careful to because the democrats will add in things after the fact if they do come up with a new package.

  • Ol’ Doc Cody

    Folks, after thirty years of dealing with other people’s sick minds I have a comment, a well-educated comment I might add, concering Barry Obama’s personality. The man is, by all text book terms, a flaming sociopath. He exhibits a vast majority of sociopathic symptomolgy. But don’t take my word for it. Now that you have the clues, reseach it for yourself. Happy hunting.

    Doc

  • TOMMY FREEDOM

    THE REPUBS NEED T CALL A NEWS CONFERENCE THAT IS NAMED ” STARTING OVER ” HEALTHCARE. INVITE THE OBUMO AND STATE WE START OVER OR WE CANNOT DO BUSINESS. THE WE THE PEOPLE HAVE REJECTED THE STATUS QUO. WE HAVE THE UPPER HAND, LETS USE IT. ITS BEEN SAID THAT OBUMO WANTS THE REPUBS TO SHOW UP FOR A PHOTO OP TO LEND CREDIBILITY AND THEN THEY WILL RAM IT THRU IN RECONCILIATION. THAT IF PASSED, WILL REVIVE HIS PUNITIVE TAXES AND AGENDA. WE ALL HAVE WORKED A YEAR TO STOP THIS PRAY WE DONT FALL IN SUCH A STUPID TRAP.

  • Robert

    The only addition I would make to the list by Dom T is to clean up (thieft and corruption) Medicare and Medicade.

    • Meteorlady

      The government has had years to try to clean up the system and they are unable to do so. To get rid of fraud and waste would cost a fortune and would require more tax dollars to hire the necessary people. The best solution was to never start these programs in the first place. Anytime you give someone something for nothing you get fraud and any time the government runs something you get waste.

    • http://Don'thaveone Sally

      Unfortunately the only way to do that under Medicare is the Medicare Advantage Plans. The insurance company is piad x amount of dollars for each and every client they have. To qualify, you have to have Plan A and Plan B Medicare. You cannot be turned down no matter what pre=existing conditions you may have. Out of what they collect, they have to pay the claims, Medicare is not billed one penny. They have contracts with various doctors that they will accept whatever payment plus co pay for various services. Co pays range from 0 to 25$ a visit depending if Dr. is a specialist or primary care. In most cases, clients pay nothing for the plan and in some instances, the plan will give back what Social Security is taking out of the check (this year it is 96.50 per month that each individual pays monthly (has to pay – they just don’t receive)is for Medicare. If you choose not to go with an HMO Advantage plan, and just have Medicare, you can buy a Supplemental Plan to pay the difference between what Medicare pays and what the charges are. This then the Dr. bills Medicare and you. If you so select this method, you also have to purchase Drug coverage which is manditory if you have Medicare only and you are penalized down the line for not having same. Or I forget, if one makes over I believe 100,000 a year AGI, then Medicare starts costing you more per month. There is a chart in your 1040 and also in Social Security and you 2010. Bush put this into law so the rich don’t get a free ride on Medicare – just so you liberals don’t get bent out of shape!!! The rich deserve their SS because they paid into the system!

  • Charles M. Hill

    The President has no respect for ideas comming from the Republicans, nor from the American people. The so called “bipartisan” summit on healthcare is simply another attempt at going around the resistance that he has run into concerning passing the bill his party has created without input or consent of the rest of the country. A president is to be a leader, not a dictator. Then there’s the issue of his proposals being unconstitutional. In no way is it propper for the government to require a citizen to buy healthcare, or any other product or service or be fined. One situation I can think of is auto insurance. That is for the protection of the citizenry. Even that is not mandated if you have sufficient means to provide for the obligations involved.

    • http://victorbarney@embarqmail.com Victor L Barney

      But he is in tune with the Marxist under the guise of “environmentalism!”

    • marvin

      driving a car is a privlage under the law and you do not have to have car insurance it is only if you drive a car millions do not own a car so there for no insurance a high school drop out in miami fl with a computer got 100 million dollars from medicare in 10 year thru fake billing a woman in virgnia working for the VA gave her staff 25 million in bonus,s the fed worker got a 2% pay increase my ss check went down

    • Meteorlady

      In a lot of states liability insurance is mandatory. In Washington state you must have proof of insurance if you are stopped. In Texas you must have proof of insurance to get your car licensed. Point is – it’s a state right – not the Federal Government’s right to impost mandatory anything on us.

      • Joe H.

        Meteorlady,
        In most of those states you DON’T have to buy insurance if you can show proof of financial responsibility, IE 50,000 cash surety or bond.

    • http://att WILLY

      MR. HILL IS RIGHT IN SAYING THAT OBAMA IS A DICTATOR.THIS IS IS MAIN FOCUS OR DREAM.HE WILL BANKRUPT AMERICA AND MAKES US A THIRD WORLD COUNTRY UNLESS THE DEMS STOP BELIEVING THE WORDS THAT COME OUT OF HIS MOUTH,FOR HE LIES.HE SAYS WHAT HE THINKS AMERICA WANTS TO HEAR:HOWEVER YOU REALLY NEED TO LISTEN TO THE WORDS,HE DOES NOT MEAN WHAT WE THINK WE HEARD.AMERICANS ARE VERY SMART AND WE DO HEAR YOU OBAMA.NONE OF THE SPOKESPERSON FROM THE WHITE HOUSE CAN BE TRUSTED.

  • Dom T

    As I understand, two alternatives are in the public domain. The first is the Democratic program which was solidly rejected and the second is various ideas proposed by the Republicans.

    I would like to see:
    - the system remains private
    - cross state insurance selling
    - tort reform
    - reduced payouts for malpractice suits
    - reduced malpractice insurance
    - mandatory insurance for anyone over 18, with one carrier from 18 to medicare age – this goes with the person from job to job
    - some form of insurance to guarantee that premiums are paid in the event of unemployment
    - no change to medicare

    The above is what I know about the German system, and what I think most closely matches the US needs.

    I don’t see the Democrats even getting near to this.

    • http://victorbarney@embarqmail.com Victor L Barney

      This also is exactly a true description of the US government plan to date under obama.

      • http://Don'thaveone Sally

        No it isn’t. Have you read the House bill? All this bill is about is more taxes on small business as well as individuals, no tort reform at all, (are you crazy – an attorney cutting himself out of business) Making all doctors whether they are a brain surgeon or a chiropractor have the same wage, tax the hospitals, BUT THE BIG POINT IS – PAY NOW BUT DON’T GET SERBIVRD FOR 4 MORE YEARS. If you want to know more, I will quote chapter and verse. I forgot the real crux of why the government wants this bill so badly – everyone will have access to not only your medical history etc., but also your finances and banking!!!!!!! And you idiots want this. Lord help us.

      • Tim

        You must be on some other planet or something. You mentioned House bill. There were actually a few different House bills that were debated on. The one that was finally voted on and passed by the full House is a good bill. It would do all the reforms that Obama had been talking about: Provide a strong public option, emphasize prevention, cover most of the uninsured, get rid of the pre-existing condition clause that insurance companies use, get rid discrimination against pregnant women, pay for itself too, bring down the cost of health care costs. How can anyone in their right mind argue with a bill like that. The tax on upper income people is legitimate. After all, they made off like bandits wih Bush’s two tax cuts.

        You must be getting your propaganda from Fox News, because you, like most of the other bloggers in here, don’t know the forest from the trees. I recommend that you watch mainstream media, instead of Fox Noise. Your mental health depends on it.

      • Joe H.

        Tim, Tim, Tim,
        If it is such a good bill and it was ready before sen Browns election, then why couldn’t he get it by the DEMS???? Why did he need the republicans at all? Now that the dems don’t have a super majority, they are trying to BS the repubs to try to get it passed without all the dems signing it by using the repubs!!! As the guy said above, don’t piss on my leg and tell me it’s raining!!!

      • http://georgessatellite@msn.com George

        now,now, Tim
        don’t get a bee in your bonnett. If you weren’t so narrow minded, you would watch FOX NEWS as well as CNN and MSNBC. You cannot get all your info from one newscast and try to be bias.

    • maggiemoo

      Ton T, are you kidding? MANDATORY health insurance? That is THE worst part of the Dems plan. I will never go for forcing me to buy something I won’t use or be able to afford.

      • Tim

        I got some news for you: The Massachusetts health care reform bill, which Scott Brown voted for and was signed into law by Republican Governor Mitt Romney, makes it mandatory for everyone to buy health insurance in the private market.

      • Joe H.

        Yeah and the state is going bankrupt because of it!!!

      • eyeswideopen

        JoeH, no it is not going bankrupt. Here is link, they even have a lower unemployment rate than the 10%, their’s is 8.7.
        http://www.bis.gov/eag.ma.htm

    • DaveH

      So, you advocate forcing people to buy a product, Dom, that throws a middle man into the cost of healthcare? Thanks a lot, or should I say “Heil!”.

  • http://www.anti-aginggenius.com Freelancelot

    Obama is both arrogant and stupid at the same time. He does not learn and cannot learn. He’s human trash. Or, should I say sub-human trash?

    • Time

      I agree that Barry is arrogant, as well an outright nasty person.
      But he is not stupid, he is as “manipulative” as anyone can be.

      Don’t trust him, if it were not for double standards he would have no standards at all. He has no moral grounding nor any interest in the American People.
      His wife said a mouth full when she said, I hate America.
      If anyone thinks Barry feels any differant, they are only fooling themselfs.

      • http://victorbarney@embarqmail.com Victor L Barney

        “Time says” is the best description of Obama so far posted!

      • marvin

        tim [al bundy look and act alike] geitner,,nancy[unamarican] pelosia..harry[the war is lost]reid,,berry[my famly is of limits but go after palin famly]obama,,charle[just pay tax you want]rangel jan[it not illegal to be in this country undocumented]nepalitano,,my point is if are goverment would stop importing over 1 million foreign worker [motel and gas station owners] close our borders 95%mexican border stop birth right citizen ship arrest and deport all illegals and there famly [and obama,s aunt] we spend 5 to 600 billions on health care a year for people that have no right to be here[health care housing food lost jobs crime] i have to obay the law. but the goverment don,t or just won,t why you ask votes to stay in power =AMNESTY=we let you stay so vote for us,, but i say in nov 2010 and 2012 if you don,t like what is going on with more and bigger not better goverment that can and will take over your life kick the bums out

      • Meteorlady

        Three prior presidents have done just that – deported illegals and stopped jobs to foreign workers. Eisenhower was the last and he deported 12 million in order to give jobs back the military personnel returning to the worker ranks. The program was very successful and took only two years to do.

        For those the believe these people take jobs citizens don’t want – please note the workers the next time you are going past a construction site. Where I live children are moving back with their parents because they have lost their jobs. These children (adults workers) are now taking jobs landscaping, mowing lawns, working in the orchards and anything else they can get to make money. So……. if we got rid of the estimated 24 to 30 million illegals in this country we might have a net job increase of say 1/2 of that – 12 to 15 million jobs back. They might not pay much, but they will keep people working and earning something.

        To do this – we would need actual politicians with balls, not the little whiney babies we have now.

      • DaveH

        Lady,
        Our shortage of jobs is not a symptom of Illegals. For, sure they should be sent back if they have broken the law. But, the Government is responsible for the Job Shortage. They are sucking up so much of our financial resources that few are left for job creation. The number of jobs outstanding is dependent only on the creativity of the citizens, and that creativity is stifled by high taxes and Government busybodies that harass those who would like to start businesses.
        Government is the Problem, Not the Solution.

      • Meteorlady

        DaveH – the government is indeed to blame. They are still issuing visas for workers. There are still many workers here on visas that last for 7 years. High tech is one of the industries where this has taken place extensively. Here in Texas the illegals are still working because they are cheap labor and they are working construction jobs which historically pay higher wages. When they are gone, the employers will have to pay at least minimum wage to get citizen workers. While I agree with you that over taxation is bad for business and jobs, I still believe that there are many many illegals and visa workers still here in this country and working. My point is that we would spend a lot less on education, health care, public housing, food stamps, etc. if we got rid of the illegals.

      • Time

        Let me just add, I got in an email early this week, it contains many statments made by Jay Rockefeller about Barry, Please keep in mind Mr. Rockefeller is a Democrat.
        “I am beging to disbelieve anything Mr. Obama says.” “He has lost his credibility on many issues.”

        Also please keep in mind this statment from Mr. Rockefeller Senate Democrat made in November 2009.
        “Neither of the heath care reform bill’s clearly display that they will not cover anyone with a preexisting medical condition.”
        “Such persons will be unable to acquire Health insurance at any cost.”
        ” These bills will without question cost the American tax payers far more than what is projected.”

        Glen Beck said, “if you think Health Insurance is expencive now, just wait until its FREE.” You think he may have a point or what?

      • Tim

        I want to respond to a few things you said:

        1) You stated that Obama lost credibility. Well, the last time I saw a poll, his approval rating was at 50%, much higher than George W. Bush’s 36% when he left office; also a lot higher than the approval rating of the top republican nominee for 2012 – Scarah Palin.

        2) You stated that the Democratic health care bills are going to cost more than what the Democrats said they would. That could happen realistically, but according to the CBO, the Senate Bill (which I have reservations about myself) would cut the federal deficit by $1 trillion over 10 years. You don’t hear this type of stuff on Fox News, because they want to brainwash people into hating Obama and the Democrats.

        3) You quoted something that Glenn Beck. I personally can’t undertstand how any intelligent person can listen to him, or even watch Fox News for that matter. See the hyperlink below about Beck. I’m telling you, the guy is a real buffoon.

        http://www.politifact.com/personalities/glenn-beck/

      • DaveH

        Comparing Bush’s ratings in his last days to Obama’s in his first year? Don’t worry, it will get worse, much worse:
        http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/obama_administration/obama_approval_index_history

        And the CBO is basing their projections on the fact that the Healthcare Bill is loaded with new Taxes that kick in far before the Healthcare costs do.

        And sure, we should listen to what a left-wing (Politifact) website says.

      • DaveH
      • Time

        Tim,
        Its very obvious your didn’t read what I posted now did you?

        If you really read what I posted you would have seen clearly I used a Democratic Senator’s own words. { Not mine.}

        If you were so inclined to grasp that the media you get your news / information from is at best bent better yet perverted.
        Let alone controlled so tighlty that when a sliver of truth is noted its clouded with 10 X’s as much complete rhetoric.

        Never at any time has opinion been equal in value to a FACT.

        Look Tim, I used a quote from Glen Beck that is what any reasonable person would note as “ON Target.” that is if they knew anything about Government run services.

        Now as to your posting of the web sight you have provided, have you in fact looked up what they have to say about Barry? It far outweighs any of the things posted on Mr. Beck.

        Also please note Mr.Beck is not the President, thus he is not held to the same standard that Barry is.
        Thus one can conclude that what you post is in fact far more daming than Mr. Beck if you wish to be held to the same standard.

        Tim you seem like a reasonable person who just can’t put the puzzel together, so may I suggest that you slow down; stop being combative then do some real looking into Barry’s backround.

        Lastly; Yes indeed GHCR will cut the def as heres why.
        “Stealing from Peter to pay Paul.”

        This is how that shell game works; All of the US pouplation will pay into a product they can’t use for 3 years, based on a simple number of 100 million X $500.00 per month X 12 X 36 = how much money that will go to pay the outstanding bonds held by China, Japan, Russia, the World bank, and all the other’s who hold this dept.

        But the question that you should be asking is where’s the money going to come from to pay for the alledged HEALTH CARE after the 36 months?
        If its gone to pay outstanding dept where’s the money coming from?

        Look Tim the Post Office is BROKE, Social Security is BROKE, Medicare is Broke, Medicaid is broke. These are all Government run.
        Ask why is that everything that the Government gets into goes broke?

        Tim, tell me about Social Security and the very begining of it.

  • thefedupamerican

    I totally agree with Melinda. Republicans should NOT go to this dog and pony show. It is political theatre designed to trap Republicans into giving them cover for this. It is in today’s news that the Democrat Leadership has already agreed upon a legislative ‘trick’ to pass healthcare via reconciliation. Republicans would be foolish to participate in this travesty. Let Dems pass this hugely unpopular bill on their own. They will own the product, the results and the consequences. http://www.thefedupamerican.com

    • DaveH

      I agree FedUp.

  • Melinda Payne

    I believe that the Republicans should refuse to meet with the President but prior to the meeting the president has planned unveil their ideas for healthcare reform. It may be difficult to get lame stream media to report but I’m certain Fox news would assist in getting the word out. We MUST stop them from jamming this down out throats.

    • Gloretha

      I am going to respond to all who think that the republicans should not do the job they are elected by law to do. ARE YOU CRAZY!!!! THAT IS TREISON IN EVERY WAY… When President Obama was elected everybody thought he could go into the white house throw Bush out and get to work. When he was sworn in they though everything would change after the republican made a big mess of everything, “NOT”
      When President Obama got in office the computer shout down he had three wars and a country that was and still is in recession and was at the point of depression, and he had to do something to stop the stock market from crashing and keep everything a float, and yes that was spending money. If Bush or another republican would have gotten into office we would have had another great depression. One thing I can say about the American people we some of us don’t see the big picture and some are very closed minded, we need something like what happened in Haiti to happened here then the people in America will be thankful for what we have as a people. it will take time to get everything back that we lost, but just be thankful that we have food and a roof over our heads. It is sad the race is playing a big part in the thing that President Obama is doing, and don’t say it’s not,it is.

      • John N.

        Congressmen, Senators, and the President were not elected to pass laws that grow the size and spending of government by leaps and bounds. They were not elected to pass laws that result in a takeover by government of the private sector. They were not elected to pass laws that set aside our freedoms as well as the Constitution. If politicians ignore the will of the people the consequence is, they will be voted out of office. This is the way our Republic works per the Constitution. Are you one of the Elitists or Progressives who want to set aside the Constitution? Do you want to enslave the people of this country to a “Big Brother” type of government? If so, then you should move to another country because this country is not for you. In spite of these Elitists and Progressives, and because of the Patriots, the United States will remain a Republic and our Constitution will stand. Patriotism is not treason and Patriots will not betray our constitution. I cannot say the same for the Elitists and the Progressives. Also, next time you make a comment, please get a dictionary for your spelling, and avoid arguments that are non sequitur.

      • Time

        Gloretha,

        Forgive me but I am confused with your post, are you saying that Barry is doing a good job? That anyone who disagree’s with that is a some how a racist?

        If so Let me address your post right here, right now. I for one don’t see color, nor race, nor religion. I take a person based on actions and abilitys that they claim they have. Thus I look at how they perform based on how they hold themselfs, as well how well they engage given their word.

        What I see in Barry is an outright lire who fails to have the American public’s best interest in mind. I see a corrupt aggressively arrogant narcissist.

      • Dorothy

        Time – May I say I agree with you 100%. I don’t even notice what
        color someone’s skin is – it has jacks____ to do with anything. Watch
        human beings eyes when they talk – are they looking at you – or at
        the wall behind you…..you can spot a liar every time that way!! No
        one lies who looks you directly in the eyes. Watch what they do and
        who they keep for close company. Bingo!!! We have a loser!!! Some
        people go off the deep end without a brain in their head!!

      • Brenda

        Gloretha….I will say that race has nothing to do with it…..you sound like the boy who cried wolf too many times……it doesn’t get you anywhere anymore, heard it too many times and it is meaningless. We don’t agree with his Progressive Marxist society that he wants us to turn into. Pure and simple. Nothing racial about that…..besides, he is half white….what’s racial about that if I’m white? makes no sense, does it?

      • DDC

        The Only Racist I See In This Picture Is Obama Himself. He Has Already Proven That. Then He Thought He Could Cover It Up By Having A Beer Party. Such A Disgrace to the ones that saw it on the news. TAX PAYERS MONEY BEING USED FOOLISHLY.

      • Tim

        You mentioned wasting the taxpayers’ money. I can think of something that did just that: That Iraq War. I would have rather had that $500 billion funding something positive, like feeding the poor, taking care of the homeless, or funding health care reform.

      • BOE

        Gloretha..you are a idiot. If we keep going by the Obama agenda it will not be long before we will not have food on the table. We..the tax payers are ruining out of money to support all of his entitlement programs like welfare,food stamps,free housing and yes even free cell phone. Obama is spending our money and China`s as fast as we make it and give it out. Race has nothing to do with it. White folks have gotten way beyond it. Unfortunely blacks folks want to keep using it as an excuse to do nothing but collect the welfare checks. Get over it! But you need to google Progressive government. Then write back. Remember folks Thomas Jefferson said “democracy ceases to exist when you take from those willing to work and give it those who are not willing to work.”

      • Tim

        Even though I think that black employees don’t work as hard as white employees most of the time, I think it is ridiculous to think that all blacks do is collect welfare checks.

        As far as taking money from the working class and giving it those who don’t work, are you trying to say that you are against giving unemployment benefits to the 9 million people who are unemployed? How would you feel, if you lost your job, through no fault of your own?

      • JeffH

        Typical liberal mush. When did he say stop the unemployment. He didn’t. Always trying to put words in others mouths.

      • SiliconDoc

        So let me get this right, Tim. You are a raving liberal demo, and you just said you think black people don’t work as hard as white people, but it’s the republicans that are racist…because you don’t think all blacks are on welfare…
        ROFLMAO !
        omg !
        HAHAHAHA

      • Gentleman Jim

        SiliconDoc, ouch! You hit Tiny Tim where it hurts the most, right in the “truth”.

      • DaveH

        It should come as no surprise to anyone that Tim is racist. After all, he is a Liberal who has no problem with riding on unwilling shoulders, just as the Southern Slave Owners had no problem riding on the shoulders of their slaves.

      • Joe H.

        Gloretha,
        am speechless and all I can say is BULL!!! CRAP!!!

      • http://comcast.net mark

        gloretha, you have got to be kidding!!

      • http://comcast.net mark

        gloretha, I will tell you what is sad. It is sad that the blacks get BET television and black history month. the whites get the damned welfare bill and called racist. I want a White history month and I want a WET television program. That would equal the bullcrap field. Blacks tend to be racist. Whites tend to be tired of hearing the whining.

      • http://acecapemob@sbcglobal.net Archie C. Beatte

        I totally disagree with Gloreatha. I totally AGREE with John N.
        Please save our Country from the Congress and the Whitehouse that is
        currently ruining it. We need smaller Washington D.C. and more State and Local as our Constitution wants it to be. Regards, A.C.E.Beatte

    • Tim

      So you think the Republicans shouldn’t be open to meeting with Obama for a discussion on healthcare? I guess you, like most Republicans, don’t believe in bipartisanship. I would bet you think that the Republicans should continue being obstructionistic.

      Why can’t you, like your tea party friends, admit that the only thing the Republicans are interested in, is to try and make Obama fail? Republicans (like Democrats) were elected to serve the public, NOT obstruct!

      • JeffH

        Tiny Tim, if Obama failed to convert this nation to a third world status through his marxist agenda and the Republicans were even partly responsible, would that be so bad?

      • DaveH

        That’s rich. So if you started to grab my wallet and I stopped you, I would be obstructionist?
        The Republicans are trying to obey their Oath to uphold the Constitution which gives no power to the Federal Government over our healthcare. Of course we can’t expect the Democrats to obey anything. Their morality left the stage many decades ago. They will lie, cheat, steal, or whatever it takes to ride on the shoulders of others.

      • George

        Tim,

        I believe if you could think like an “independent” for a minute and not like a partisan Democrat, I’m pretty sure you’d come to the conclusion that this legislation has been rushed through Congress such that very few people really know what is in it. I’m sure the American people aren’t confident that they know what’s in these bills. In fact, we know that several Congressmen and the President on occasion, when asked what was in the bill, have failed to answer the question correctly, so it looks like they aren’t all that sure either. We know that legislation like this is quickly written by Congressional staffers with the help of representatives from the industries affected by the legislation. If we’re not careful and push legislation through the process before it is thoroughly vetted by everyone, we will most likely get bad legislation. Of course, that won’t keep politicians from boasting about passing the legislation. What do they care anyway? They’ve exempted themselves from this legislation. We really need to start over and craft a bill that a strong majority of Americans can sign-up to. If the Democrats find a way of getting this past Congress with a majority of Americans opposed to it and no bi-partisan support, the Democrats will likely pay a heavy price in coming elections, and the American people will suffer from a poorly crafted program for years to come.

      • Joe H.

        Tim,
        i have read and reread your posts many times here and I have a favor to ask of you. Since you believe in Obummers way so well, could you send me about say 20,000 in cash? that’s about all I need to pay off my house, build a new garage and buy some new welders to open my business!!!25,000 would be better but I’ll settle for the lesser of the two as it’s a bad time for the economy!!! Get the point I’m making????

    • Only in America

      The republicans are the party of obstruction. Nothing is new. Most of them are in wall streets pocket.

      We the people to them must mean we the lobbyists.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Bottom